Odd Bits: Converting OpenSSH public keys

This is an interesting read.

Odd Bits: Converting OpenSSH public keys.

Converting OpenSSH public keys

> I’ve posted a followup to this article that discusses ssh-agent.

For reasons best left to another post, I wanted to convert an SSH public key into a PKCS#1 PEM-encoded public key. That is, I wanted to go from this:

ssh-rsa AAAAB3NzaC1yc2EAAAADAQABAAABAQD7EZn/BzP26AWk/Ts2ymjpTXuXRiEWIWn HFTilOTcuJ/P1HfOwiy4RHC1rv59Yh/E6jbTx623+OGySJWh1IS3dAEaHhcGKnJaikrBn3c cdoNVkAAuL/YD7FMG1Z0SjtcZS6MoO8Lb9pkq6R+Ok6JQjwCEsB+OaVwP9RnVA+HSYeyCVE 0KakLCbBJcD1U2aHP4+IH4OaXhZacpb9Ueja6NNfGrv558xTgfZ+fLdJ7cpg6wU8UZnVM1B JiUW5KFasc+2IuZR0+g/oJXaYwvW2T6XsMgipetCEtQoMAJ4zmugzHSQuFRYHw/7S6PUI2U 03glFmULvEV+qIxsVFT1ng3pj [email protected]

To this:

-----BEGIN RSA PUBLIC KEY----- MIIBCgKCAQEA+xGZ/wcz9ugFpP07Nspo6U17l0YhFiFpxxU4pTk3Lifz9R3zsIsu ERwta7+fWIfxOo208ett/jhskiVodSEt3QBGh4XBipyWopKwZ93HHaDVZAALi/2A +xTBtWdEo7XGUujKDvC2/aZKukfjpOiUI8AhLAfjmlcD/UZ1QPh0mHsglRNCmpCw mwSXA9VNmhz+PiB+Dml4WWnKW/VHo2ujTXxq7+efMU4H2fny3Se3KYOsFPFGZ1TN QSYlFuShWrHPtiLmUdPoP6CV2mML1tk+l7DIIqXrQhLUKDACeM5roMx0kLhUWB8P +0uj1CNlNN4JRZlC7xFfqiMbFRU9Z4N6YwIDAQAB -----END RSA PUBLIC KEY-----

If you have a recent version of OpenSSH (where recent means 5.6 or later), you can just do this:

ssh-keygen -f key.pub -e -m pem

If you don’t have that, read on.

OpenSSH Public Key Format

The OpenSSH public key format is fully documented RFC 4253. Briefly, an OpenSSH public key consists of three fields:

  • The key type
  • A chunk of PEM-encoded data
  • A comment

What, you may ask, is PEM encoding? Privacy Enhanced Mail (PEM) is a specific type of Base64 encoding…which is to say it is a way of representing binary data using only printable ASCII characters.

For an ssh-rsa key, the PEM-encoded data is a series of (length, data) pairs. The length is encoded as four octets (in big-endian order). The values encoded are:

  1. algorithm name (one of (ssh-rsa, ssh-dsa)). This duplicates the key type in the first field of the public key.
  2. RSA exponent
  3. RSA modulus

For more information on how RSA works and what the exponent and modulus are used for, read the Wikipedia article on RSA.

We can read this in with the following Python code:

import sys import base64 import struct # get the second field from the public key file. keydata = base64.b64decode( open('key.pub').read().split(None)[1]) parts = [] while keydata: # read the length of the data dlen = struct.unpack('>I', keydata[:4])[0] # read in bytes data, keydata = keydata[4:dlen+4], keydata[4+dlen:] parts.append(data)

This leaves us with an array that, for an RSA key, will look like:

['ssh-rsa', '...bytes in exponent...', '...bytes in modulus...']

We need to convert the character buffers currently holding e (the exponent) and n (the modulus) into numeric types. There may be better ways to do this, but this works:

eval = eval('0x' + ''.join(['%02X' % struct.unpack('B', x)[0] for x in parts[1]])) nval = eval('0x' + ''.join(['%02X' % struct.unpack('B', x)[0] for x in parts[2]]))

We now have the RSA public key. The next step is to produce the appropriate output format.

PKCS#1 Public Key Format

Our target format is a PEM-encoded PKCS#1 public key.

PKCS#1 is “the first of a family of standards called Public-Key Cryptography Standards (PKCS), published by RSA Laboratories.” (Wikipedia). You can identify a PKCS#1 PEM-encoded public key by the markers used to delimit the base64 encoded data:


This is different from an x.509 public key, which looks like this:

-----BEGIN PUBLIC KEY----- ... -----END PUBLIC KEY-----

The x.509 format may be used to store keys generated using algorithms other than RSA.

The data in a PKCS#1 key is encoded using DER, which is a set of rules for serializing ASN.1 data. For more information see:

Basically, ASN.1 is a standard for describing abstract data types, and DER is a set of rules for transforming an ASN.1 data type into a series of octets.

According to the ASN module for PKCS#1, a PKCS#1 public key looks like this:

RSAPublicKey ::= SEQUENCE { modulus INTEGER, -- n publicExponent INTEGER -- e }

We can generate this from our key data using Python’s PyASN1 module:

from pyasn1.type import univ pkcs1seq = univ.Sequence() pkcs1seq.setComponentByPosition(0, univ.Integer(nval)) pkcs1seq.setComponentByPosition(1, univ.Integer(e_val))

Generating the output

Now that we have the DER encoded key, generating the output is easy:

from pyasn1.codec.der import encoder as derencoder print '-----BEGIN RSA PUBLIC KEY-----' print base64.encodestring(derencoder.encode(pkcs1_seq)) print '-----END RSA PUBLIC KEY-----'

Appendix: OpenSSH private key format

Whereas the OpenSSH public key format is effectively “proprietary” (that is, the format is used only by OpenSSH), the private key is already stored as a PKCS#1 private key. This means that the private key can be manipulated using the OpenSSL command line tools.

The clever folks among you may be wondering if, assuming we have the private key available, we could have skipped this whole exercise and simply extracted the public key in the correct format using the openssl command. We can come very close…the following demonstrates how to extract the public key from the private key using openssl:

$ openssl rsa -in key -pubout -----BEGIN PUBLIC KEY----- MIIBIjANBgkqhkiG9w0BAQEFAAOCAQ8AMIIBCgKCAQEA+xGZ/wcz9ugFpP07Nspo 6U17l0YhFiFpxxU4pTk3Lifz9R3zsIsuERwta7+fWIfxOo208ett/jhskiVodSEt 3QBGh4XBipyWopKwZ93HHaDVZAALi/2A+xTBtWdEo7XGUujKDvC2/aZKukfjpOiU I8AhLAfjmlcD/UZ1QPh0mHsglRNCmpCwmwSXA9VNmhz+PiB+Dml4WWnKW/VHo2uj TXxq7+efMU4H2fny3Se3KYOsFPFGZ1TNQSYlFuShWrHPtiLmUdPoP6CV2mML1tk+ l7DIIqXrQhLUKDACeM5roMx0kLhUWB8P+0uj1CNlNN4JRZlC7xFfqiMbFRU9Z4N6 YwIDAQAB -----END PUBLIC KEY-----

So close! But this is in x.509 format, and even though the OpenSSL library supports PKCS#1 encoding, there is no mechanism to make the command line tools cough up this format.

Additionally, I am trying for a solution that does not require the private key to be available, which means that in any case I will still have to parse the OpenSSH public key format.